National Adaptation Framework on Climate Change – still a long way to go

Last September a public consultation on the National Adaptation Framework on climate change  was launched by the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment and we, at GEAI, submitted our opinion, making thirty-seven recommendations.

The document gave a fairly comprehensive overview of the projected impacts of climate change in Ireland d illustrated the governance process to be put in place for adaption. Nonetheless, on reading the draft it is evident that there is an element of “passing the buck” to the local authorities in terms of climate change adaptation.

2009 floods in Carrick-on-Shannon (Ph. Leitrim Observer)

In our view it is crucial that Government takes its own ambitions of being a “Leader in Climate Action” seriously and shows courage and determination in setting appropriate goals and targets to achieve this.

The National Adaptation Framework highlights the local authorities as key actors at the front line to fight against climate change. Even though we agree that local authorities will play a significant role, we argued that they must be supported with further appropriate financial and human resources.

If Government is not seen to provide leadership on Ireland’s response to climate change; if it does not tackle with appropriate legislative measures the three main causes of our high carbon emissions – the use of fossil fuels in energy generation and heating; meat production without adequate waste treatment measures; and our fossil fuel-guzzling transport sector – than it is not reasonable to expect and adequate response from regional or local levels.

Furthermore, we believe that the regional level could create an important forum for discussion for localised climate action. We therefore suggest the establishment of Climate Action and Resilience Groups, with a statutory status, where three or four counties geographically close to each other  coordinate to ensure more effective information sharing processes and, consequently, more cooperation. The country-wide Public Participation Networks must also be considered as vehicles to boost Climate Action and provide opportunities for discussion.

Other suggestions presented included, for instance, establishment of local smart grids to protect power supplies in the event of extreme weather conditions; mainstreaming of climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction concepts into sectoral policies and plans; new overarching school curricula on climate action and climate justice to be developed and implemented at all stages of education; ensuring that resources are made available for extreme weather adaptation measures at household level for communities and vulnerable groups of people.

Read our full submission


Microgeneration vital in the move towards a low carbon economy

We at GEAI responded to the public consultation on the Design of a new Renewable Electricity Support Scheme (RESS) launched the 04th of September 2017 by the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment.

The consultation document contains an economic assessment of a new RESS in Ireland followed by an assessment on how to increase community participation and suggestion of a model. Our response focussed mainly on the section “providing pathways for increased community participation” and microgeneration.

In our view, micro-scale electricity generation is a very crucial step towards a low carbon transition. However, this vision seems not to be fully shared by the Department.


Rooftop solar PVs

In fact, the RESS report states that “the relative cost of micro-generation is very high” and cites the example that domestic rooftop solar PV is 4100/MWh more expensive than large and medium solar PV in 2020. It then concludes that “meeting renewable electricity targets and renewable diversity ambitions are more cost effectively achieved at large and medium scale levels”. For the above mentioned reasons it is then proposed that “microgeneration would not be supported via the main RESS”.

We think this conclusion is based solely on economic grounds, which does not take into consideration the added value of getting the community’s goodwill and commitment to make the change to renewables.

Furthermore, rural areas play an important role in the transition towards a low carbon economy and community participation is the key of this process, mainly because it has the potential to revitalise rural areas through reskilling workers, creation of local jobs (e.g. installers, maintenance) that would keep workers in their communities and generating new income streams for businesses and farms.

A microgeneration support scheme would engage householders and farmer’s attention; it would introduce them to the possibility of change in their sources and uses of energy; it would make them more amenable to consider new ways of doing things.

In particular, if the individual feels that he/she is being supported to participate in the new world of renewables, this will make them far more amenable to support proposals for larger-scale developments such as wind farms.

Another consideration is that, despite some projects being designated as community-led under the scheme, the perception will remain that renewable energy projects are again examples of developers coming into a community and imposing changes on residents to “their” landscape that they have not agreed to nor want.

Where there is dissatisfaction, there will be active opposition. To win the hearts and minds of communities who already are opposed to wind turbines (for example) will take more than talk about community benefits; the better approach is to give them ownership of their own energy future.

At this stage, people know that we have to change the way we do things. A supported microgeneration scheme is the best way of allowing the change to start.

Read our full submission


Citizen’s Assembly proposals for tackling Climate Change – Our View

GEAI would like to congratulate the Citizen’s Assembly for their challenging decisions addressing the key issues Ireland faces in its fight against Climate Change.

The Citizen’s Assembly is a body including a Chairperson – the Honourable Mary Laffoy – and 99 citizens, drawn to represent the whole of their compatriots when addressing crucial issues meant to impact Ireland’s future. On Sunday the 5th of November, they gathered for the second time to reflect on “How the State Can Make Ireland a Leader in Tackling Climate Change”. After two weekends of debating, the Assembly members voted in favour of 13 recommendations:

  • In order for Climate Change to have its rightful importance in our political landscape, a new or existing independent body should be given the legislative power and the financial resources to address this issue, and to challenge the State if it fails do so itself.
  • It was unanimously decided that the State should act as a leader in tackling Climate Change through mitigation measures such as improving energy efficiency of public buildings and promoting low carbon vehicles and renewable energy sources.
  • 80% of the members stated that they would accept to pay more taxes on carbon intensive activities; with the condition that poorer households will be exempt from it (the 400 000 households currently in receipt of fuel allowance).
  • The State should acknowledge the risks our country’s infrastructure faces with Climate Change impacts – such as extreme weather – and evaluate their costs to include it on the amount spent in this sector.
  • Irish citizens should be given the possibility to sell back to the grid the electricity they produce on their land through microgeneration. The price for it should at least be equivalent to the wholesale price.
  • Communities should be encouraged by the State to be involved in future energy projects as well as developing their own. Developer-led projects would have the obligation to give them share options.
  • In the next 5 years, the State should stop funding peat extraction and invest instead in restoring peatlands and in helping the workers transferring to another activity sector.
  • Bus lanes and cycling facilities should be greatly improved in the next 5 years and made more attractive for traveller to take instead of their private cars.
  • The switch from traditional cars to electric cars should be heavily facilitated by the State as soon as possible.
  • Improving and expanding public transport should be a priority, especially in rural areas.
  • The agricultural sector should be taxed whenever the amount of greenhouse gas its activity produces is excessive. In return, farmers who manage to lower the carbon footprint of their work should be rewarded with subsidies. The excess of money coming from those taxes should stay in the agricultural sector, to promote more sustainable practices.
  • Food waste should be closely monitored at every level of food distribution so measures can be taken to reduce it efficiently.
  • The State should support diversity in land use with a special attention given to reforesting the country and developing organic farming.

GEAI supports all those proposals made by the Citizen’s Assembly and is particularly enthusiastic about the energy related ones.

We agree that promoting and funding renewable energy sources needs to be a top priority for our country to become a leader in the fight against Climate Change.  However, we are disappointed that other than supporting a feed-in tariff, there was no motion to include support for microgeneration as a priority. The exclusion of microgeneration in the draft Renewable Electricity Support Scheme (RESS) means that farmers, small businesses and householders are excluded from a vital part of the transition to low carbon economy and lifestyle, especially in rural areas.  We advocate a reversal of this decision and are making a submission to the RESS accordingly.

The report that will be drawn from those proposals will hopefully prioritise an increase of the use of renewable energy sources and microgeneration.  It is vital that Government takes into account these points.



  • “Higher taxes and more bus lanes: How the Citizens’ Assembly wants Ireland to tackle climate change”, Orla Ryan –, 5/11/2017
  • “Citizens’ Assembly votes for radical overhaul of Irish climate change policy”, Niall Sargent –, 5/11/2017
  • Design of a new Renewable Electricity Support Scheme in Ireland: September 2017

A New Climate for Education – an important Seminar

Last Friday, at the Teacher’s Club in Dublin, a seminar “A New Climate for Education“ was held, to discuss how Climate Change and sustainability are incorporated into schools curricula. This was organised by Green Foundation Ireland, Cultivate, GEAI and ECO – UNESCO.

Aedín McLoughlin, Director of Good Energies Alliance Ireland and the GEAI EVS volunteers attended this event.  During the morning there were really interesting presentations from the ecologist and TV presenter, Duncan Stewart; Breda Naughten from Dept. Of Education; and Peadar Kirby, Professor Emeritus at the University of Limerick. Young people had an opportunity to express their views and time was given for discussion on how best to implement climate change studies in schools.

The most memorable quotes that we took away with us included:

An increase in temperature of three and a half degrees is going to make our planet uninhabitable, and we need to get this information into the schools. We’re on borrowed time. We’re taking young people’s future, it’s a serious situation.” (Duncan Stewart)

“Are we sowing the seeds of new values, new energies, new questing people? Or are we conforming to the system?” (Peadar Kirby)

“I think the most important thing is that we don’t make anything worse. Each euro spent in an investment in the world we live in.” (Ben Mallon)

Also memorable was the great contribution by young people to the discussion.

You can find more information about the event itself here.


® All rights reserved to GEAI 2018